“Is this your best work? A case for professional development
When Henry Kissinger was Secretary of State, any staffer who approached Kissinger with a report or document he/she had drafted could expect to hear the following question from the esteemed Secretary: “Is this your best work?”
Talk about a loaded question. How do you answer that? It’s like the question, “Do you still beat your dog?” No good answer there either. Think about it.
Put yourself in the mind of the State Department staffer pondering how to respond to his boss.
Kissinger: Is this your best work?”
Staffer (you) thinking: If I say “yes”, and Kissinger finds weaknesses or errors, I’ve just declared that shoddy work is the best I can do. If I say “no”, I can expect to be blasted for submitting less than my best work. But at least I’ve left myself wiggle room, some benefit of the doubt.
I could hedge and say that it’s the best I could produce under the time constraints. Then I leave myself open to the threat of being replaced by someone who can do better “under the time constraints.”
Oh man, damned if I do; damned if I don’t. OK, I’ll hedge.
It’s my best work, sir, under the time constraints.
Kissinger: I see. Why don’t you go re-work it and come back when it is your best work?
It’s about time
The former Secretary of State’s recommendation reminds me of the old business dictum: “There’s never enough time to do it right; but always time to do it over.” This truism raises the corollary question, “How do I do my best work by minimizing or eliminating doing it over?” One answer is to get better. Easy to say; how does one raise his/her game while playing the game?
The Japanese had an answer in the 70s and, which they adopted from American quality/productivity expert, W. Edward Demmings. Demmings’ improvement prescriptions were issued to American industrial giants following the Korean War in response to what he correctly perceived as a quality deficit that would sooner than later leave the GMs , GEs, and U.S. Steels at a competitive disadvantage to foreign corporations. They didn’t heed the message. Can you say, Toyota and Sony, boys and girls?
The Japanese used a buzzword to summarize the Demmings approach, kaizen, Continuous improvement. Applied to the overall organization, kaizen is a way of managing work processes so that managers and workers are always looking for ways to improve the process, reduce product defects, streamline supply chains, manage inventory, improve marketing and sales, bind customer loyalty, and so on.
Tom Peters, 80s management guru, became a Demmings apostle and preached the gospel of ongoing organizational development in seminal works such as In Search of Excellence and Passion for Excellence. American business got the message.
If it is to be, it’s up to me
Since the whole is the sum of its parts, and the chain is only as strong as its weakest link, it follows that individual continuous improvement is a means to moving entire organizations closer to its a-game. We call this professional development, and it begins with taking personal responsibility for your own professional improvement. Formal education usually precedes occupational practice. Professional development is the in-game education and skill-building that allow workers and managers to initiate an ongoing process of personal kaizen.
Pathways to Personal Excellence
Demmings outlined 14 steps to business success. Let’s apply four of the ones that can be adapted to a personal application for achieving personal business success through continuous professional development.
1. Create a constancy of Purpose. In his own seminal work, The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, Stephen Covey emphasizes the importance of beginning with the end in sight. In other words, know what you’re aiming at, define your purpose. Purpose gives meaning; it separates essential tasks from unimportant activities. Make professional development a priority based on career goals. In your industry, business, or profession, what do you really want to accomplish? Take the development steps to move in that direction. Would a graduate degree contribute to your purpose? A Professional certification? Attendance at a conference? Membership in an applicable organization? Individual study in a relevant content area? Forming productive relationships with others?
2. Adopt a new philosophy. Covey calls it a paradigm shift, the way you view something. Are conditions in your business environment changing, but you are “doing business” based on your knowledge of and comfort with former conditions. Think buggy whips here. Do you need to learn/adapt a new technology? Or assimilate new buyer demographics and motivations?
3. Drive out fear. The business environment is always changing. Change engenders concern, sometimes fear. Embracing the change doesn’t necessarily mean agreeing with it. It does mean adapting effectively to it. Adaptation always involves learning. In fact, learning is the basis of adaptation. Think dinosaurs here. Remember when you knew basic math but had not learned Algebra? Or how about becoming involved in a new sport? You adapted by learning new content and developing/perfecting new skills, and then applied those new “problems.” Knowledge and skill building yield confidence. Confidence reduces fear.
4. Involve others. You’re 100% responsible for your own results, (see above), but you don’t have to do it alone. Seek the viewpoints, advice, and support of others who have demonstrated proficiencies that align with your purpose. Mentors, coaches, champions of professional development in other departments or even other (non-competing) companies. They have already plowed the ground you may have just set foot on. Tap into what they’ve learned and tried successfully.
Is this your best work? Only you know for sure. If it’s not, now you have a pathway to personal excellence. Be like Dorothy and her flawed friends: follow it.